• 28 Cottage Ave, Bay Shore, NY 11706
Book Your Table

HOURS & LOCATIONS

28 Cottage Avenue | Bayshore, NY 11706
(631) 666-2899 | info@fatfish.info

OPEN FOR 2026 SEASON
Friday, April 10th 11:30am 
 APRIL HOURS 
 Sunday – 11:30am – 6pm
 Monday – closed
 Tuesday – Saturday 
 lunch 11:30am – 3:30pm
 dinner 4:30pm – 9pm 
 HAPPY HOUR 
 4-6PM – WEEKDAYS 
copyright @2026 All Rights Reserved

From Long Island Expressway

  • Exit 53 Bay Shore South Sagtikos Pkwy to Southern State Pkwy.
  • Merge onto Heckscher St. Pk. on the left. Merge to right lane.
  • Exit is about 1/4 mile. Exit 42S, Fifth Ave.
  • Turn left on Spur Drive South.
  • Turn right onto Fifth Avenue.
  • Continue to follow Fifth Avenue about 3 miles. Fifth Ave becomes S. Clinton Avenue.
  • Take to end. Just before Bay Shore Marina booth, make a right in the parking lot.
  • Turn left out of parking lot.

From Montauk Highway

  • To YMCA / St. Patrick’s Church South on S. Clinton Avenue.
  • Take to end.
  • Just before Bay Shore Marina booth, make a right in the parking lot.
  • Turn left out of parking lot.

From Southern State Parkway

  • Exit 42S, Fifth Avenue.
  • Turn left on Spur Drive South.
  • Turn right onto Fifth Avenue.
  • Continue to follow Fifth Avenue about 3 miles.
  • Fifth Ave becomes S. Clinton Avenue. Take to end.
  • Just before Bay Shore Marina booth, make a right in the parking lot.
  • Turn left out of parking lot.

From Sunrise Highway

  • Exit 43S Fifth Avenue.
  • Continue to follow Fifth Avenue about 2 miles.
  • Fifth Avenue becomes S. Clinton Avenue. Take to end.
  • Just before Bay Shore Marina booth, make a right in the parking lot.
  • Turn left out of parking lot.
Newsletter